The Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

There are so many things you have to keep track of when you have a baby. Pacifiers are likely one thing you probably won’t dwell on too much. However, if you are a breastfeeding mama, you may be asking yourself, what are the best pacifiers for breastfed babies?

Finding the best pacifier for breastfed babies could be the key to giving your body the rest it needs. 

The Popular Option
Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Baby Pacifier, Girl - 0-6m, 4pk, Pink
Best Overall
Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier, 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, SCF190/41
Most Convenient
MAM Start Newborn Pacifiers (2 pack, 1 Sterilizing Pacifier Case), Newborn Baby Boy Pacifiers, Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies, Self Sterilizing Baby Pacifier Case
Tommee Tippee
Philips Avent Soothie
MAM Start Pacifier
The Popular Option
Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Baby Pacifier, Girl - 0-6m, 4pk, Pink
Tommee Tippee
Best Overall
Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier, 0-3 Months, Green, 4 Pack, SCF190/41
Philips Avent Soothie
Most Convenient
MAM Start Newborn Pacifiers (2 pack, 1 Sterilizing Pacifier Case), Newborn Baby Boy Pacifiers, Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies, Self Sterilizing Baby Pacifier Case
MAM Start Pacifier

These are some of the best pacifiers for breastfed babies with some of the highest customer ratings on the market right now. If you’re looking for a new binkie for your little one, you can’t go wrong with any of these choices.

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

Mama’s Choice: Best Overall

The Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier has over 4,000 fabulous reviews, and for good reason. It’s one of the most common pacifiers out there because it is widely available in hospitals. So if you don’t buy one ahead of time, there’s a good chance you’ll be going home with one. 

Sale
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier
The Philips Avent Soothie is as simple and straightforward as a pacifier gets. It has a one-piece orthodontic design and is made with durable but flexible medical-grade silicone that offers a natural feel.

What I Love

  • Promotes suckling and bonding
  • Easy to sterilize 
  • Used by doctors
  • Respects the development of baby’s teeth and gums
  • Durable medical-grade silicone

This pacifier doesn’t look special and is lacking some of the cute features you might see on other pacifiers, but that’s part of the charm. Your baby isn’t going to care whether the pacifier looks cute or catches their attention, they’re going to worry about how it feels in their mouth.

The medical-grade silicone is durable but flexible and mimics the natural shape of a nipple. That will give this pacifier a natural feel and is less likely to cause nipple confusion.

Check Price

Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier

Mama’s Choice: The Popular Option

The Tommee Tippee Pacifier is coming in a close second with strong reviews and beautiful construction. If you have been looking for a pacifier that is easy for your baby to hold onto, this is it. Babies love it because it is lightweight, flexible, and feels natural.

Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Silicone Pacifier
The Tommee Tippee Pacifier is ultra-lightweight, comfortable, and the perfect tool to use to help your little one learn to soothe themselves. It comes in multiple sizes, and they will be able to hang onto it with ease.

What I Love

  • Comes in multiple sizes
  • Made with 100% food-grade silicone
  • Easy to clean
  • Has a smooth skin-like feel
  • Stays in their mouth with ease

This design is simple and looks similar to most of the pacifiers you would see in stores. However, the Tommee Tippee pacifier is lightweight and the ideal shape for many newborns. The design and materials make it comforting to any baby who is used to breastfeeding. 

Check Price

MAM Start Pacifier

Mama’s Choice: Most Convenient Pacifier

MAM isn’t a familiar brand for many new moms, but it certainly should be when it comes to pacifiers. The Start Pacifier has a simple design, but it is perfectly suited for newborns who need a little extra comfort.

MAM Start Pacifier
The MAM Start Pacifier has a symmetrical design, so your little one can never put it in the wrong way. It has a silicone nipple, comfortable shield, and mimics the feel of a mother's breast for maximum comfort.

What I Love

  • The Asymmetrical shape
  • Natural feeling silicone nipple
  • Comfortable shield helps prevent rashes
  • Self Sterilizing case

The Start pacifier is simple but has all the features you need for mother and baby. It has the perfect asymmetrical shape, so your baby can never put the pacifier in the wrong way. Plus, it comes with a sterilizing case for a mother’s peace of mind on the go. 

Check Price

How to Choose the Best Pacifiers for Breastfed Babies

When it comes to choosing the best pacifiers for breastfed babies, there are three simple factors you need to focus on:

  • Size
  • Material
  • Shape

You may have noticed that pacifiers come in different sizes. Picking a specific size for their age will help ensure that the pacifier is safe and will cause less discomfort and confusion.

Next, you need to think about the material. Rubber and silicone are two of the most popular options for pacifiers. That’s a good thing for breastfed babies because the soft and flexible feel of these durable materials feels the most natural and skin-like.

Last, the shape of the pacifier is very important. We included orthodontic and regular options on our list, but you may find that your baby prefers the natural shape more. That is the long and slender shape with a rounded tip. 

However, there are certain perks to the orthodontic shapes, and it is absolutely worth trying both shapes.

Important Factors to Consider When Choosing a Baby Pacifier

When it comes to any baby pacifier,  there are a few things you need to consider along the way: 

  • Your baby isn’t always going to like pacifiers. So picking the right one may take some trial and error.
  • One-piece pacifiers are extremely convenient because they’re easier to keep clean and very durable.
  • Orthodontic pacifiers are a great option for babies because they are better for your children’s tooth and gum development. However, breastfed babies may not like them.
  • You’re going to lose pacifiers all the time. Once you find your little one’s favorite type, make sure to stock up on a few and have them on hand. 

Other Pacifiers You Should Consider

We may have covered the top three pacifier options so far, but there is a never-ending list. To narrow down some of the best runner-ups, we want to give you a few more fabulous options.

Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Pacifier

The Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother is another fantastic choice with excellent ratings and a ton of color options. This pacifier is wonderful for breastfed babies because the material and shape make it more realistic. 

Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother
The Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother is made with food-grade silicone for a soft but durable feel.

What I Love

  • Made with 100% food-grade silicone
  • 11 color options to choose from
  • Two air holes for safety
  • One-piece construction makes it very easy to clean

What’s Meh

  • Everything sticks to them
  • The nipple is a bit large which makes it better for 3-months and up

Overall this is a very cute pacifier. It’s soft and flexible, comfortable, and gets fantastic reviews. It’s a great pacifier to keep in mind if your baby prefers larger pacifiers or needs something that will grow with them.

Check Price

RaZbaby Jollypop Baby Pacifier

The RaZbaby Jollypop pacifier is another wonderful choice. This is one of the few pacifiers that can be found in hospitals being distributed in NICU’s.

RaZbaby Jollypop Baby Pacifier
The RaZbaby Jollypop pacifier is a beautiful option for a newborn baby, made with medical-grade silicone and the perfect shape for growing teeth and gums.

What I Love

  • Made in the USA
  • Trusted in hospitals
  • Medical-grade silicone
  • Orthodontic design
  • Dishwasher and sterilizer safe

What’s Meh

  • Not always easy for the baby to keep in their mouth

The RaZbaby Jollypop Pacifier is a well-known and trusted brand. While not every baby will accept these pacifiers, they are a wonderful choice if you’re trying all kinds.

Check Price

Dr. Brown’s HappiPaci 

Dr. Brown’s HappiPaci has over 4,000 excellent reviews. It’s soft, lightweight, and comfortable. 

Dr. Brown's HappiPaci
This is a one-piece silicone pacifier with a familiar nipple shape, butterfly-shaped shield, and durable construction.

What I Love

  • Durable silicone
  • Natural nipple shape
  • Dishwasher and sterilizer safe
  • Easy to hold onto

What’s Meh

  • Can be difficult to keep in their mouth

The HappiPaci has another straightforward design but it is well loved and perfect for breastfed babies. 

Check Price

Nanobebe Flexy Pacifier

The Nanobebe Flexy Pacifier has a unique design that is meant to comfortably form to your baby’s mouth. It is one of the best tools to help your child learn how to self soothe between feedings.

Nanobebe Flexy Pacifier
The Nanobebe is a one-piece silicone pacifier that comes in two different sizes. It's flexible and gentle on teeth and gums.

What I Love

  • Shaped to stay in your baby’s mouth
  • Helps them self soothe
  • Flexible and comforting
  • BPA and Phthalate free

What’s Meh

  • Not very similar to a breast, more like a bottle

Overall, this is not at the top of the list because it does have a similar look and feel to a bottle than a breast. However, it could be worth a try if your child doesn’t like anything else because this design is extremely easy for them to hold onto.

Check Price

Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Day Time Soother

Tommee Tippee is hitting the list again today with the closer to Nature Day Time Soother. It is a very popular pacifier with over 2,000 glowing reviews. It comes in two different sizes and is perfect for use teaching you baby to swap between breast, bottle and pacifiers.

Sale
Tommee Tippee Closer to Nature Day Time Soother
The Closer to Nature Day Time Soother is in incredibly soft silicone pacifier that is meant to provide a soothing experience for your little one.

What I Love

  • Naturally orthodontic
  • Extremely soft silicone
  • Curves away from the babies face for more airflow
  • Designed to avoid nipple confusion

What’s Meh

  • Must be cleaned and dried carefully to prevent mold

Tommee Tippee has become a big name with pacifiers, it’s no wonder they made the list twice. They pay close attention to the details of their product and the needs of your child which make them well-worth a try.

Check Price

Closing Thoughts

As every parent will tell you, when it comes to picking a pacifier, it’s not up to you. The baby is either going to love a pacifier or spit it out immediately. 

While they are extremely useful to teach your baby how to self-soothe, which is very helpful when breastfeeding, they are not necessary. In fact, you shouldn’t give a breastfed baby a pacifier for the first six weeks or until you have established a good feeding routine. 

Don’t be afraid to ask fellow mama’s for help and suggestions—picking the right pacifier can be challenging, but the options above give you a place to start.

Scroll to Top